Weekly Winners 2023 - 01

06 Jan
by Arjen

Happy New Year everyone! We're excited for the upcoming year and the new cards that will come with it. Some leaks from Phyrexia: All Will Be One yesterday, but so far we're not seeing this reflected in the interests. Of course, this could change in the next few days as more people see them. But for right now we're looking at some Commander cards that are trending up.

Like every week, just in time for FNM, I'll tell you about the cards that will be the talk of the town tonight! Come discuss this week's price movements with us on Discord and Reddit.

Articles

Last week on A Penny Saved, Ryan showed us three cards worth picking up and playing.

Also last week we released the Year in Review articles where we showed you which cards moved the most in 2022. There are three articles in total, with different tables in each of them, so make sure you check them out!

If you want to receive an e-mail in your inbox when a new article is published you can enable it in your e-mail preferences and/or join the Discord.

Onto the Weekly Winners!

#1 Benevolent Hydra $24.88 (+179%)

Benevolent Hydra

 

This rare from Jumpstart 2022 briefly spiked to $250 on the average price chart this week. This is clearly a fluke, but that doesn't mean that something isn't happening with the card. Similar to Hardened Scales, with this card in play, you get to put extra +1/+1 counters on your creatures. You can also use the Hydra to put these counters on different creatures as well.

The card obviously is easily included in Commander decks that also play Hardened Scales. Even if you don't have the spare mana to put into , it's worth it to just play in for for some extra value. The later you draw this card, the better it becomes when you do have the mana available to put a larger creature into play. And it's a Hydra, which is a popular creature type in Commander. Gargos, Vicious Watcher is one of the earlier, and more popular, commanders for Hydras, and I wouldn't be surprised to see it showing up in these decks, as well as newer commanders like The Swarmlord or Runadi, Behemoth Caller.

As I mentioned, the card spiked tremendously on the average price chart, but the price has since come down again to more normal levels. Currently the average price sits around $25, coming from $15 before the spike, and around $7 in early December. The market price however also went up the past week from about $8 to $20. So people are definitely buying into this card.

On the same note, we're seeing a rare from the first Jumpstart moving up slowly as well. This card is Branching Evolution, which has a similar effect: extra +1/+1 counters for your creatures.

Branching Evolution
Benevolent Hydra
Gargos, Vicious Watcher
Branching Evolution

 

#2 Klauth's Will $3.00 (+97%)

Klauth's Will

 

Klauth's Will is an instant from Commander: Adventures in the Forgotten Realms, and I am frankly a bit surprised it doesn't see more play. It works perfectly in Dragon Commander decks where all your creatures are flying, and the artifact and enchantment hate seems pretty good as well. Even though you get to have 100 cards in your deck in Commander, players do love to have some versatility in their cards to limit the amount of dead draws in any stage of the game. And if you control your commander, you even get to play both modes.

Shockingly enough, we see this card being played in... Klauth, Unrivaled Ancient decks. Klauth can generate a bunch of mana when it attacks, and then you can pump that mana into Klauth's Will. Sounds like a fine interaction. We discussed Klauth in September as a winner because of the extra popularity of Dragons that came with Miirym, Sentinel Wyrm.

Klauth, Unrivaled Ancient
Klauth's Will

 

#3 Drannith Magistrate $14.18 (+29%)

Drannith Magistrate

 

Since we're only discussing commander cards, lets look at everyone's favorite Commander card! Drannith Magistrate is a card you usually play when you want to make friends, right? This Human Wizard can prevent your opponents from playing spells from anywhere other than their hands. Since commanders are played from the command zone, Drannith Magistrate simply prevents your opponents from being able to play them! Fun ensured!

In the last couple of weeks, many people on social media were asking for the card to be banned. So what happened? It went up in price because it drew a lot of extra attention to the card. According to some, Drannith Magistrate goes against the spirit of Commander, since the format revolves around being able to cast and re-cast your commander. If you do decide to play it in your decks, and to make sure you will have extra friends, pair it with either Omen Machine or Urabrask, Heretic Praetor. When you have Drannith Magistrate in play along with one of those two other cards, you effectively shut everyone down. They have to be able to get rid of one of these cards with a card in their hand, otherwise they won't be able to play anything except the cards they currently have in hand.

But Drannith Magistrate doesn't just see play in Commander. It's also showing up a bunch in Modern sideboards as a way to beat strategies around Underworld Breach, since it completely shuts down that card.

Urabrask, Heretic Praetor
Omen Machine
Drannith Magistrate

 

Cheap Pickups

Please note: for our 'record low' we consider the price of the card over the past 7 years. Many cards have been even cheaper (a) decade(s) ago. Also note: some cards are still going down, and might be even cheaper pickups next week.

 

Living Death $4.81 - Moving up!
Living Death

 

Living Death has been identified by the MTGStocks Premium Penny Stocks feature as a card that has reached its bottom and is starting a consistent uptrend.

 

Liliana, the Last Hope $6.74 - Slowly moving down
Liliana, the Last Hope

 

Monastery Mentor $7.45 - Slowly moving down
Monastery Mentor

 

Living Death
Monastery Mentor
Liliana, the Last Hope

 

That's it for this week. Make sure to check back next week for more Weekly Winners!

Arjen

Arjen

Arjen has been playing Magic since the Ice Age set released. He primarily plays Legacy format and founded MTGStocks over a decade ago when he and his friends wanted to track card prices to purchase singles at optimal times.


More from Arjen:

Weekly Winners 2026 - 06

Feb 6, 2026

The Pro Tour has been affecting prices. People are trying to put their favorite deck from the top 8 together!

Arjen

Weekly Winners 2026 - 05

Jan 30, 2026

The Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles set hasn't even dropped yet, but the Secrets of Strixhaven set is already having an impact on a very old card.

Arjen

Weekly Winners 2026 - 04

Jan 23, 2026

Premodern is increasingly making prices move. But since today is Lorwyn Eclipsed release, we'll also see spikes because of that.

Arjen

Weekly Winners 2026 - 03

Jan 16, 2026

Not unsurpsingly Lorwyn Eclipsed is making the market move. And just like last week it mainly seems to come from the precons which seems to be very popular.

Arjen

Weekly Winners 2026 - 02

Jan 9, 2026

The Lorwyn Eclipsed precons really drove people to get upgrades. With the entire deck lists previewed, we now know which cards got a reprint and which didn't.

Arjen

Weekly Winners 2026 - 01

Jan 2, 2026

Happy new year! This week's number one winner is because of Premodern. We also have Commander cards, and cards going up in anticipation of the Lorwyn Eclipsed spoilers coming up next week.

Arjen

Yearly Winners 2025: Cheapest Prints (Part 4)

Jan 2, 2026

The fourth article in the "Yearly Winners 2025" series tailors its analysis based on community feedback. It offers a refined look at MTG card values, focusing on the cheapest versions of cards and excluding 2025 prints.

Arjen

Yearly Winners 2025: Absolute Value (Part 3)

Jan 2, 2026

Unveil the most dramatic price shifts of 2025 in our third Yearly Winners analysis! This exclusive report focuses on absolute dollar changes, revealing the biggest movers in the market.

Arjen

Yearly Winners 2025: The Reserved List (Part 2)

Jan 1, 2026

Explore the Reserved List's triumphs and downfalls in our latest Yearly Winners article! Uncover the top 100 MTG cards that made waves in 2025.

Arjen

Yearly Winners 2025: Top Winners and Losers (Part 1)

Jan 1, 2026

Explore the biggest winners and losers of 2025 as we break down the year's most significant price movements and market trends across Magic: The Gathering.

Arjen