Weekly Winners 2025 - 43

24 Oct
by Arjen

While the market is cooling down a bit, anticipating the release of the next set, the upcoming PlayStation Secret Lair drop is stirring prices a bit.

Like every week, just in time for FNM, I'll tell you about the Magic: the Gathering cards that'll be the talk of the town tonight! Come discuss this week's price movements with us on Discord.

Articles

Check out our other great content from this week.

The Path of Small Magic Sets by Harvey McGuinness

The Modern Meta of the Pro Tour by Corey Williams

If you want to receive an e-mail in your inbox when a new article is published, you can enable it in your e-mail preferences and/or join the Discord.

Onto the Weekly Winners!

#1 Rashel, Fist of Torm $17.43 (+57%)

This card is a tricky one - at least, the name is. Because if you look closely at the bottom border of the card, you'll see "=SLD 1237," which means that she should be considered the same as Xenk, Paladin Unbroken. Xenk was printed first as part of the D&D: Honor Among Thieves Secret Lair drop. Since Xenk, and the other cards in that drop, are all functionally unique, Wizards reprinted them as part of their "Universes Within" program under a different name.

But for deckbuilding purposes these cards are to be treated the same as their Universes Beyond counterparts, meaning that in a Commander deck you can't play both Xenk and Rashel together.

Jin Sakai, Ghost of Tsushima

With that out of the way, let's talk about the card and why it spiked. Xenk is a Human Knight creature with double strike that gives Auras you control exalted. The main reason I can see right now is because of the upcoming card Jin Sakai, Ghost of Tsushima from the Secret Lair x Playstation which will go on sale on Monday.

Jin Sakai incentivizes players to let creatures attack alone, because when they're the only creature attacking a player, it either gains double strike or can't be blocked. The difference being that Jin Sakai will let you attack multiple players with a single creature to trigger and exalted only triggers when you attack with just one overall. Nevertheless, the synergy is here as they're both cards that want creatures to attack alone.

Interestingly, it seems like only the Rashel print has been moving up and Xenk hasn't changed. This likely has to do with her being far cheaper than Xenk and is merely catching up. That said, Xenk may still move if Jin Sakai turns out to be a popular commander.

Rashel, Fist of Torm
Xenk, Paladin Unbroken
Jin Sakai, Ghost of Tsushima

#2 False Cure $7.03 (+44%)

Our next winner recently turned 23 years old. False Cure is an instant that is considered a "bad" card, because if you play it by itself, it doesn't do anything. It turns life gain into life loss, and does it at double the speed. This means that the card works really well against life gain decks, but that niche occurrence doesn't seem to be the reason for the card moving up.

False Cure sees some play in Premodern, but these decks aren't tier 1 or even tier 2. The deck tries to play cards with an alternative cost in the form of letting your opponent gain life together with False Cure to win. Skyshroud Cutter or Reverent Silence can let your opponent gain five or six life and thus lose your opponent ten or twelve life just by putting them on the stack.

I feel the more likely reason for the recent uptick is because of a new commander printed in Marvel's Spider-Man. Mister Negative lets you exchange life totals with target opponent. When you play this deck you want to hurt yourself, using your life as a resource to get life total low, while also getting card advantage out of it. An important ruling for this deck is:

When life totals are exchanged, each player gains or loses the amount of life necessary to equal the other player's life total. For example, if one player has 10 life and the other has 17 life, the first player gains 7 life and the other one loses 7 life. Replacement effects may modify these gains and losses, and triggered abilities may trigger on them

This means when you exchange life, you actually gain or lose life in the process. This also means that if we exchange life with an opponent who's at a lower life total than we are, we get to draw cards because of Mister Negative, but False Cure will make sure they lose far more life than they gained in the process. We can also Flicker Mister Negative to trigger its enters ability again.

False Cure
Mister Negative

#3 Ghostly Pilferer $2.30 (+93%)

Interesting card moving up, and the reason for it seems like people speculating. If I ask Commander players what the best card draw engine is in a Commander pod, most of them would probably say Rhystic Study. And they'd be correct. There's a good reason that it's on the Game Changers list, and the price also reflects how popular the card is. Currently a copy will set you back around $50.

Last Tuesday Wizards released their Commander Brackets Update where they get into the brackets and what they mean. They also made changes to the cards on the Game Changers list, removing several of them from it, but also discussed cards that they kept on it. One of the cards that will stay on that list is Rhystic Study, and they got into the card itself mentioning that it's an iconic Commander card, but they're not so sure whether the format is more fun with the card, questioning whether it should be banned instead.

With the ban-hammer potentially looming above the card, people are speculating on what card could replace it in their decks. And you guessed it, one of the more commonly referenced cards is Ghostly Pilferer. It seems that people are just getting their copies in case Rhystic Study gets banned and they feel it's a decent replacement. I don't see it, to be honest, but sometimes (or pretty often) the Magic market doesn't necessarily make sense.

Other cards being mentioned as replacement are Mystic Remora and Insight, depending on your deck, obviously.

Ghostly Pilferer
Rhystic Study
Mystic Remora
Insight

Cheap Pickups

Please note: for our 'record low' we consider the price of the card over the past seven years. Many cards were even cheaper (a) decade(s) ago. Also note: some cards are still going down, and might be even cheaper pickups next week.

Tidal Barracuda $4.63 - Moving up!

Tidal Barracuda has been identified by the MTGStocks Premium Penny Stocks feature as a card that has reached its bottom and is starting a consistent uptrend.

Mutavault (CLB) $3.99 - Moving down

Tannuk, Steadfast Second $4.44 - Moving down

Tidal Barracuda
Mutavault (CLB)
Mutavault
Tannuk, Steadfast Second

Arjen

Arjen

Arjen has been playing Magic since the Ice Age set released. He primarily plays Legacy format and founded MTGStocks over a decade ago when he and his friends wanted to track card prices to purchase singles at optimal times.


More from Arjen:

Weekly Winners 2025 - 46

Nov 14, 2025

Playstation cards and Jaws are responsible for two of our winners this week. The last one is because of a rediscovered combo.

Arjen

Weekly Winners 2025 - 45

Nov 7, 2025

The PlayStation Secret Lair drop is responsible for two of our winners, and the other winner seems to have fallen victim to speculation.

Arjen

Weekly Winners 2025 - 44

Oct 31, 2025

People are still looking for their Rhystic Study replacements. But this week is mostly about cards from Universes Beyond: Warhammer, Avatar, and Spider-Man.

Arjen

Weekly Winners 2025 - 42

Oct 17, 2025

Spider-Man is making some impact, and the Ninja Turtles are claiming their first spike. But our number one winner is because of Legacy!

Arjen

Weekly Winners 2025 - 41

Oct 10, 2025

I hope you like old cards, because two of our Winners may be older than you are.

Arjen

Weekly Winners 2025 - 40

Oct 3, 2025

This week we're discussing Commander, Premodern, and Modern - a fun mix of formats. And we're also talking about Spider-Man.

Arjen

Weekly Winners 2025 - 39

Sep 26, 2025

Card prices seem stable at the moment, while Spider-Man releases today. This week we're talking Lorwyn and Legacy!

Arjen

Weekly Winners 2025 - 38

Sep 19, 2025

It seems like people are anticipating the Spider-Man release and more Avatar previews, and it shows. It's been a bit of a slow week, but fortunately there's still plenty to talk about.

Arjen

Weekly Winners 2025 - 37

Sep 12, 2025

Our number one winner is because of Premodern, but all-in-all it's been a relatively slow week. But even then there's enough to talk about!

Arjen

Weekly Winners 2025 - 36

Sep 5, 2025

Edge of Eternities is stirring things up in Standard and Modern while the metagame is trying to find new decks.

Arjen