Cards to Watch from Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles

25 Feb
by Matt Grzechnik

Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles is not the strangest Universes Beyond product, and by some stretch, not the most complex. It is a rather small set, akin to what we have seen from Marvel's Spider-Man. If you found yourself having fun learning about the different origins of Spider-Man and the many notable characters, then this is a similar, albeit more niche experience.

What I see as the biggest issue is that Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles are somewhat more obscured from pop culture, but still have a rather extensive history, which is portrayed through many different art styles. In regard to whether this is a faithful representation of the heroes in a half shell, I canโ€™t tell you with all honesty. However, for judging whether these are decent Magic cards that may or may not see play or a rise in value, Iโ€™m your guy.

Resleeving All Rats

Starting off with the bonus cards, there are definitely some choices given here that I didnโ€™t anticipate seeing. In this case, this is definitely a good thing as the chase cards are better than some random, obscure playable that got printed 20 years ago.

The big one is a Jumpstart 2022 reprint, which hopefully continues this trend of overvalued cards due to scarcity consistently climbing in price. Ashcoat of the Shadow Swarm (Borderless) is a reskinning of Ashcoat of the Shadow Swarm. It is one hell of an ugly card that reminds me more of ALF than anything else. 

All comments on visuals aside, Ashcoat of the Shadow Swarm was well on its way to go from $80 to $100, perhaps due to the anticipation of this set. But now with a functional reprint, I see the price going back toward the $70 range between the two copies, and hopefully, we can see some more effective reprintings further down the line.

A common joke I hear is the Universes Beyond Masters set coming down the line at some point. I think Jumpstart Masters, combining some of the high points from these products, would be much easier to arrange.

Two additional cards from the bonus sheet to keep an eye on are Doubling Season and All Will Be One. We have seen Doubling Season being included previously on bonus sheets, which has helped to curb its overall price, at least for a while. All Will Be One has been more scarce, with only a recent Secret Lair printing and also a nice curve up in value ahead of the Lorwyn Eclipsed release.

For the Doubling Season, pick up your cheaper copies where you can, as there will be a marginal decrease in price following two weeks of release. All Will Be One, if opened, should be sold sooner rather than later. The card is primed for more reprintings or treatments further down the line. Otherwise, it's still a little bit too expensive to be a promising long-term speculation.

Fighting on Favored Terrain

The Commander product has surprised me a bit, given the effort that someone at Wizards went through making sure there was a functional five-color mana base. The lands included in the Turtle Power! deck is nothing short of a money printing machine going BRRRrrrr. 

Pardon the joke here, but the lands are just that good. With both battle and bond lands being included in the deck, as well as City of Brass, Iโ€™m genuinely happy for anybody interested in picking the deck up. Personally, I would be leaning towards buying it and ruthlessly pulling it apart for parts, given my sentiment towards the theme.

Other notables from this deck include Continue?, which is now my new favorite way of bouncing back from everyone moving out of using Farewell as a catch-all. Four creatures without limit of being legendary or having the same type, with the only limitation being that it has to be this turn. 

No matter how I slice it, this reads like an above-rate protection spell that carries 35-40% of power in comparison to Teferiโ€™s Protection. Price-wise, it will likely start low, with many of these decks being opened for the context. After 1-2 months, I can see Continue? bouncing back into the $5-10 range with a slightly higher ceiling in two years.

Mutations and Munitions

There is a bit of traction caused by the mythics in the main set so far which is pretty standard as far as prerelease prices are concerned. Most of the hype cards will fall in price completely sooner rather than later. For an example, I want to take a look at the current financial point of interest, Super Shredder.

By itself, Super Shredder is a build-around card requiring permanents to be churning through the battlefield. Could it grow quickly and efficiently by itself, provide an immediate impact to the board, prevent some kind of interaction, or require immediate removal? No. Super Shredder is a rather flat legend which needs more work than itโ€™s worth. Currently, the Standard Meta is occupied by Izzet Lessons, Mono-Green Landfall, and Dimir Midrange/ Combo. None of these decks really grind through permanents that quickly, so Standard is out of the question.

Modern has its own slew of decks, which again are a little bit too quick and more resilient to single threats. With that, Super Shredder may be more of a Commander card, but there are still better options for that type of Aristocrat deck, like Sephiroth, Fabled SOLDIER. All of that in mind, I think Super Shredder will be a $5 card sooner rather than later, unless Iโ€™m missing some obvious interaction.

A brief mention of The Ooze, which is a powered-down version of The Ozolith, or at least the closest comparison point. The Ooze is not going to win you the game by itself, but is primed to be part of the engine you create for value. Due to this, I strongly think that more than one deck is going to look at the creation of the tokens as more of a positive rather than the each combat payoff its older sibling is offering. All going well, The Ooze will remain a $10-15 card with a rather small reprinting window.

Many MTG Players Ask

Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles is a small-scale set tied up in a bow and given to players among a slew of Universes Beyond products. Is that a good thing or a bad thing? Thatโ€™s up to you to decide.

Personally, Iโ€™m still of the opinion that if you donโ€™t like something that Wizards ships out, you arenโ€™t missing out. There are so many products being introduced almost every month that it's nearly impossible to keep up. Select whatever you actually want, have a bit of fun speculating, or just wait a month till we are back on Strixhaven. The choice is always yours and doesnโ€™t always need to be the same.

Join me again next time as we are due for another Secret Lair Commander release.

Read More:

Checking in With Modern Masters

Matt Grzechnik

Matt Grzechnik

Matt Grzechnik started playing Magic with the release of Dragon's Maze. Since then he has tried and experimented with all of the formats before discovering his love for EDH and Pauper. Piloting the same Jund deck for the last 10 years, he now tries to both understand and break Sealed as a format.


More from Matt Grzechnik:

2025 MTG Year in Review

Jan 14, 2026

Matt looks back at the previous year of his article series New Horizons to determine the best of the best in Magic: The Gathering for 2025.

Matt Grzechnik

Secret Lair Countdown: An Encyclopedia of Value?

Dec 10, 2025

Wizards recently released a Secret Lair advent calendar. Do the cards inside it justify the $200 price tag?

Matt Grzechnik

Cards To Watch From Avatar: The Last Airbender

Nov 12, 2025

Now that all of the cards have been revealed for Avatar: The Last Airbender, let's look at the set and its ancillary products to see if the hype is real.

Matt Grzechnik

What's Going On With Secret Lairs?

Oct 15, 2025

MagicCon Atlanta had a Secret Lair panel that revealed a huge number of drops, including Secret Scare and PlayStation.

Matt Grzechnik

Cards To Watch From Marvel's Spider-Man

Sep 10, 2025

Now that all of the cards from Marvel's Spider-Man have been revealed, let's take a look at which cards from the set are worth watching for investment.

Matt Grzechnik

Cards To Watch in the Sonic Secret Lair

Aug 13, 2025

The Sonic the Hedgehog Secret Lair includes three separate drops, one of which has several mechanically unique cards. Which should you pick up?

Matt Grzechnik

Cards to Watch From Edge of Eternities

Jul 30, 2025

Which cards from Edge of Eternities are gonna be hot? Which ones will drop like a rock when the set releases? Let's discuss.

Matt Grzechnik

Cards to Watch From Final Fantasy

Jun 11, 2025

Which cards from Final Fantasy are worth speculating on, and which ones will drop like rocks? Let's discuss.

Matt Grzechnik

The Value of the Secret Lair Commander Deck Everyone's Invited

May 14, 2025

Based on previous Secret Lair Commander deck releases, what can we predict about the value of the new deck, Everyone's Invited?

Matt Grzechnik

What's Good In Tarkir: Dragonstorm?

Apr 16, 2025

Does Tarkir: Dragonstorm live up to the hype? Is it as good as the original Tarkir block? Let's take a look.

Matt Grzechnik