Banned & Restricted Announcement December 4th 2023

It's that time again, when the Magic community braces for the latest Banned and Restricted announcement from Wizards of the Coast. As of December 4, 2023, we're seeing some significant changes across multiple formats. Let's dive into the details and understand the rationale behind these decisions.

Pioneer Shake-Ups

Karn, the Great Creator and Geological Appraiser have been shown the exit door in Pioneer. Karn's versatility and ability to fetch game-winning combos from the sideboard made it a stifling presence, warping the meta around itself. Geological Appraiser, on the other hand, was enabling turn-three wins, which was deemed too oppressive for the format's health.

In a surprising twist, Smuggler's Copter makes a comeback! Previously banned in December 2019, this versatile Vehicle is expected to add interesting dynamics to the format without overpowering it.

$0.34 $0.49

$4.32 $1.49

Modern Adjustments

Fury and Up the Beanstalk are the cards facing the ban hammer in Modern. Fury, particularly in Rakdos Evoke and Four-Color Omnath decks, was suppressing creature-based strategies with its potent board-clearing ability. Up the Beanstalk, a recent addition, was enabling high-cost spells way too early, disrupting the balance of play.

$3.82 $4.99

Legacy and Vintage: Steady as They Go

No changes here, folks! Both Legacy and Vintage are maintaining their current lists. It's always fascinating to see how these formats, with their vast card pools, manage to self-regulate and adapt over time.

Explorer Aligns with Pioneer

With Explorer being Pioneer's digital counterpart on MTG Arena, it's no surprise that Karn, the Great Creator and Geological Appraiser are banned here as well. However, Smuggler's Copter remains absent from Arena, so no changes there.

Pauper's Swift Change

Monastery Swiftspear is now banned in Pauper. This card has been a powerhouse in aggressive decks, and its removal is aimed at diversifying the format's strategies.

The Why Behind the What

Wizards of the Coast's decision-making process is always intriguing. For Pioneer and Explorer, the goal is to maintain a diverse and healthy meta where multiple strategies can thrive. Karn's omnipresence and Geological Appraiser's fast-track wins were counterproductive to this vision.

In Modern, the bans of Fury and Up the Beanstalk aim to open up the format to a wider variety of decks and strategies, especially those involving creature play, which Fury was heavily suppressing.

Pauper's ban of Monastery Swiftspear is a move towards ensuring a more varied and balanced format, preventing the dominance of overly aggressive strategies.

Wrapping Up

These changes, effective from December 4, 2023 on tabletop and Magic Online, and December 5, 2023 on MTG Arena, are sure to shake things up across formats. For a more detailed look, check out the official announcement from Wizards of the Coast here.

As always, the Magic community is abuzz with reactions and speculations. Which decks will rise? Which ones will adapt? Only time, and a whole lot of shuffling, will tell. Happy deckbuilding, and may your draws be ever in your favor!