Weekly Winners 2023 - 09

03 Mar
by Arjen

This week we have a nice mix of Modern, Commander, and Legacy to talk about. Usually these weeks are my favorite, and there is plenty of stuff happening in Magic land.

Like every week, just in time for FNM, I'll tell you about the cards that will be the talk of the town tonight! Come discuss this week's price movements with us on Discord.

Articles

Sometimes people don't understand why a card is expensive. In Ryan's article series Price of Knowledge he explains exactly why that is, and this week he covered Painter's Servant.

Matt talked about the Phyrexia: All Will Be One Jumpstart set and which cards to keep an eye on in his New Horizons series. This is definitely a series to watch if you want to stay up to date on upcoming sets and which cards could have an impact.

If you want to receive an e-mail in your inbox when a new article is published you can enable it in your e-mail preferences and/or join the Discord.

Onto the Weekly Winners!

#1 Shining Shoal $11.10 (+640%)

Shining Shoal

 

Here's an older card from Betrayers of Kamigawa shooting up. This instant can reflect damage done to you or a creature you control by either paying its mana cost or by pitching a card. Shining Shoal has recently been seeing play in Modern Mono White Human decks as anti-Fury tech.

Fury sees a lot of play in multiple formats, but mainly in Modern where it's a popular inclusion in a variety of decks. Being able to Evoke it makes it some cheap removal when you have to get rid of some creatures. Decks like Izzet Aggro, Rakdos, and Elementals all include copies either mainboard or in the sideboard. You can imagine that for decks with small creatures, like Humans, it can be backbreaking to have a single card 4-for-1 you (or 4-for-2 you when Evoked). That is why Shining Shoal is now seeing play in these decks to prevent some damage done to creatures and to keep your board.

Since Shining Shoal is a rare card from an older set with only a single print, the price shoots up easily when it becomes more popular. Funnily enough the last time this card spiked was in May 2017 when it made the Top 8 in the Modern GP Vancouver the month prior. Jason Simard played two copies in his Mono-White Eldrazi & Taxes deck. Back then it shot up to $6.17 from less than a dollar and has slowly dwindled back down again to about $1.10 until this week.

 

#2 Phyresis Outbreak $8.75 (+386%)

Phyresis Outbreak

 

Here is a more recent rare from Commander: Phyrexia: All Will Be One that is quickly becoming popular. The card can be found in the Corrupting Influence Commander Deck and has broken out. With all the new love for poison counters it can be a valuable sweeper for just 3 mana. Worst case, you can use it to give all of your opponents a poison counter for .

A quick look at EDHREC quickly reveals how popular this card is. Commanders we see the card played in are, among others, Ixhel, Scion of Atraxa, Karumonix, the Rat King, and Vishgraz, the Doomhive.

Ixhel, Scion of Atraxa
Karumonix, the Rat King
Vishgraz, the Doomhive

 

#3 Cephalid Illusionist $2.88 (+60%)

Cephalid Illusionist

 

Now that we have discussed a winner for Modern and Commander, I'm happy to also find a card on this week's Interest list that could be discussed because of Legacy to have a nice rounded-out mix of cards! Cephalid Illusionist is an uncommon from Torment that has never seen a reprint. And while copies can still be had for $2.88 since it went up with 60% it's also notable that the foils went from $25 to $150.

This is not an unknown card for anyone who knows a thing or two about Legacy. It used to be included in a popular archetype called Cephalid Breakfast. When we look at Cephalid Illusionist we see that whenever it becomes targeted you have to mill three cards. This means that if we're able to target it repeatedly, we get to mill many, many, many cards. Nomads en-Kor enables us to redirect one damage from one target creature. And this is a bit odd, but you can activate this ability an infinite amount of times targeting your Cephalid Illusionist, thus milling your entire library. Milling yourself can win you the game with the right deck, and this deck makes sure that it can get Thassa's Oracle out to win the game with an empty library.

While Thassa's Oracle is a relatively new card, there have been ways to win with this combo before it, going all the way back to 2007. Just like now you get to put Narcomoeba onto the battlefield and use Dread Return. So far the deck still functions the same nowadays, but back then you would bring back Karmic Guide, which could bring back Kiki-Jiki, Mirror Breaker, which in turn can copy the Karmic Guide. With this copy you can return Sky Hussar to the battlefield. That card can untap Kiki-Jiki, which can in turn create another copy of Sky Hussar, which will untap Kiki-Jiki, making an infinite amount of Sky Hussars with haste.

Karmic Guide
Kiki-Jiki, Mirror Breaker
Sky Hussar

 

Cheap Pickups

Please note: for our 'record low' we consider the price of the card over the past 7 years. Many cards have been even cheaper (a) decade(s) ago. Also note: some cards are still going down, and might be even cheaper pickups next week.

 

Tamiyo's Journal $3.48 - Moving up!
Tamiyo's Journal

 

Tamiyo's Journal has been identified by the MTGStocks Premium Penny Stocks feature as a card that has reached its bottom and is starting a consistent uptrend.

 

Time Stretch (Retro Frame) $5.17 - Slowly moving down
Time Stretch (Retro Frame)

 

Kibo, Uktabi Prince $9.99 - Slowly moving down
Kibo, Uktabi Prince

 

Primeval Titan (494) $5.00 - Slowly moving down
Primeval Titan (494)

 

Primeval Titan (494)
Time Stretch
Time Stretch (Retro Frame)
Time Stretch (Borderless)
Kibo, Uktabi Prince
Tamiyo's Journal

 

That's it for this week. Make sure to check back next week for more Weekly Winners!

Arjen

Arjen

Arjen has been playing Magic since the Ice Age set released. He primarily plays Legacy format and founded MTGStocks over a decade ago when he and his friends wanted to track card prices to purchase singles at optimal times.


More from Arjen:

Weekly Winners 2026 - 06

Feb 6, 2026

The Pro Tour has been affecting prices. People are trying to put their favorite deck from the top 8 together!

Arjen

Weekly Winners 2026 - 05

Jan 30, 2026

The Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles set hasn't even dropped yet, but the Secrets of Strixhaven set is already having an impact on a very old card.

Arjen

Weekly Winners 2026 - 04

Jan 23, 2026

Premodern is increasingly making prices move. But since today is Lorwyn Eclipsed release, we'll also see spikes because of that.

Arjen

Weekly Winners 2026 - 03

Jan 16, 2026

Not unsurpsingly Lorwyn Eclipsed is making the market move. And just like last week it mainly seems to come from the precons which seems to be very popular.

Arjen

Weekly Winners 2026 - 02

Jan 9, 2026

The Lorwyn Eclipsed precons really drove people to get upgrades. With the entire deck lists previewed, we now know which cards got a reprint and which didn't.

Arjen

Weekly Winners 2026 - 01

Jan 2, 2026

Happy new year! This week's number one winner is because of Premodern. We also have Commander cards, and cards going up in anticipation of the Lorwyn Eclipsed spoilers coming up next week.

Arjen

Yearly Winners 2025: Cheapest Prints (Part 4)

Jan 2, 2026

The fourth article in the "Yearly Winners 2025" series tailors its analysis based on community feedback. It offers a refined look at MTG card values, focusing on the cheapest versions of cards and excluding 2025 prints.

Arjen

Yearly Winners 2025: Absolute Value (Part 3)

Jan 2, 2026

Unveil the most dramatic price shifts of 2025 in our third Yearly Winners analysis! This exclusive report focuses on absolute dollar changes, revealing the biggest movers in the market.

Arjen

Yearly Winners 2025: The Reserved List (Part 2)

Jan 1, 2026

Explore the Reserved List's triumphs and downfalls in our latest Yearly Winners article! Uncover the top 100 MTG cards that made waves in 2025.

Arjen

Yearly Winners 2025: Top Winners and Losers (Part 1)

Jan 1, 2026

Explore the biggest winners and losers of 2025 as we break down the year's most significant price movements and market trends across Magic: The Gathering.

Arjen