Hidden Gems for Captain America, First Avenger

10 Dec
by Adam Berg

Even though copies of the Marvel Secret Lair legendary creatures arenโ€™t yet readily available, theyโ€™re already proving to be quite popular as commanders. Over at EDHREC, the most popular commander of the past month is Storm, Force of Nature - which we covered last time. After her, Captain America, First Avenger has thousands of people brewing.

Strategies diverge down different paths, from equipment to voltron to aggro to combo. As you consider your own brew and reevaluate after playtesting, there are bound to be cards to go in and out of your build. Here are five recommendations that might get overlooked or underappreciated - at least when it comes to maximizing the fun and not necessarily the win rate.

#1. Bludgeon Brawl

Flinging random equipment can already create entertaining images, like using Hot Soup or Chariot of Victory. Picture them bouncing off of enemiesโ€™ noggins and youโ€™re already having more fun than your opponents. If we want to expand the hilarity and open up Captain Americaโ€™s arsenal to any artifact, Bludgeon Brawl promises the world. Use a Darksteel Forge to protect your equipment and deal nine damage between three targets. Who knew a forge could be so bouncy?

Bludgeon Brawl

#2. Akki Battle Squad

Whenever you build a deck around Auras, Equipment, or artifacts, donโ€™t forget to search for cards that care about modified creatures. This little battle squad works great with Captain America, since his second ability triggers at the beginning of combat and will most likely be modified. Itโ€™s like doubling up on his leadership skills! Plus, why wouldnโ€™t he want to lead a battalion of Goblin Samurai? It just makes sense. 

Akki Battle Squad
Akki Battle Squad (Extended Art)

#3. Rohirrim Chargers (Borderless)

While weโ€™re venturing into the world of Universes Beyond, letโ€™s add a little Lord of the Rings to the mix. This Human Knight fetches up Equipment whenever it attacks, but only if it exerts, meaning it probably wonโ€™t be attacking every turn. That is, unless you find ways to untap it, like the aforementioned Akki Battle Squad. At four mana, it starts with a decent body of 4/4, plus whatever Equipment you happen to fetch and attach to it right away. Itโ€™s a great way to keep up the pressure while also gaining card advantage. For Rohan!

Rohirrim Chargers (Borderless)

#4. Karn, Legacy Reforged

Karn does it all! Since weโ€™re already loading up on Equipment, his power and toughness scales upwards as whatever Equipment you find comes into play. Hello Excalibur, Sword of Eden! But he also contributes mana to cast artifact spells and pay for abilities - including the Captainโ€™s first ability that allows all the โ€œshieldโ€ tossing that heโ€™s become famous for. With a mana hungry ability like that, the Captain is gonna want to ramp up. But unfortunately for him, Americaโ€™s colors donโ€™t include green; hereโ€™s where Karn shines. It never really comes up in the movies, but Steve Rogers' best friend is actually Karn. Surprising, I know.

Karn, Legacy Reforged
Karn, Legacy Reforged (Foil Etched)
Karn, Legacy Reforged (Retro Frame)
Karn, Legacy Reforged (Extended Art)
Karn, Legacy Reforged (Future Sight)

#5. Copy Artifact

Itโ€™s not the most obvious copy ability for artifact synergies, since we have the likes of Phyrexian Metamorph, Sculpting Steel, and Masterwork of Ingenuity. But if we want to add more copying options to the mix, a two-mana enchantment is a great rate and a good way to impress the old fogey at the table who misses the good old days of 1994. Itโ€™s on the Reserved List though, making it only slightly more annoying to find than an actual copy of the Captain. At least for now.

Copy Artifact
Copy Artifact
Copy Artifact

Thatโ€™s all for this week on Hidden Gems. Donโ€™t forget to check out our Premium membership for more entertainment and Magic market insights!  Until next time, happy brewing!

Further Reading:

The Best Ways to Break "Once Each Turn" Cards in Commander

Adam Berg

Adam Berg

Adam started playing Magic on his 14th birthday, when Judgment just released and the game's first Gorgon was born (It's a girl!). Since then, he's delved deep into Commander, written for television and film, and learned how to drive. He's published two YA Fantasy novels, Rainbringer and The Broken Pantheon. His favorite card is Repay In Kind, which is really all you need to know.


More from Adam Berg:

Hidden Gems for Fire Lord Azula

Nov 18, 2025

Looking to find some neat tech for your Fire Lord Azula Commander deck? Hidden Gems has you covered.

Adam Berg

Hidden Gems for Norman Osborn // Green Goblin

Oct 7, 2025

Looking for some unique cards for your Norman Osborn Commander deck. This edition of Hidden Gems has you covered.

Adam Berg

Hidden Gems for Hearthhull, the Worldseed

Sep 9, 2025

Looking to make your Hearthhull Commander deck a little more unique? Then we've got some hidden gems here for ya.

Adam Berg

Hidden Gems for Ragost, Deft Gastronaut

Aug 5, 2025

Looking for some unique ideas to fill out the 99 of your Ragost, Deft Gastronaut Commander deck? Hidden Gems is here to help.

Adam Berg

Hidden Gems for Yโ€™shtola, Nightโ€™s Blessed

Jul 8, 2025

Looking for some more unique picks for the 99 of your Y'shtola, Night's Blessed Commander deck? We've got you covered.

Adam Berg

Hidden Gems for Vivi Ornitier

Jun 3, 2025

Vivi Ornitier is one of the most popular legends from the new Final Fantasy set. Let's see what cards people are overlooking for him in their Commander decks.

Adam Berg

Hidden Gems for Deadpool, Trading Card

May 6, 2025

Looking to make your Merc With a Mouth Commander deck more unique? This Hidden Gems is here to help.

Adam Berg

Hidden Gems for Teval, the Balanced Scale

Apr 8, 2025

Looking to make your Teval deck a bit more unique? Then check out these great cards that most players are overlooking.

Adam Berg

Hidden Gems for Sarkhan, Dragon Ascendant

Mar 4, 2025

We're still several weeks away from Tarkir: Dragonstorm, but that doesn't mean we can't get brewing with one of the revealed legends.

Adam Berg

Hidden Gems for Hashaton, Scarab's Fist

Feb 4, 2025

Aetherdrift is just around the corner, so we're digging up some hidden gems for one of its most popular commanders, Hashaton, Scarab's Fist.

Adam Berg