Checking in on the Modern Meta After Pro Tour Modern Horizons 3

03 Jul
by Corey Williams

With Pro Tour Modern Horizons 3 in the books, there’s a lot to talk about. Looking at the day one metagame breakdown, we can see Modern has had a dynamic makeover compared to the pre-MH3 meta, with Nadu encompassing around 20% of the day one competitors and Ruby Storm not too far behind. So what cards are moving as the meta takes shape? And moreover, how well is the meta now defined? Let’s dive into a few big movers in the market!

Phlage, Titan of Fire's Fury

Uro, Titan of Nature's Wrath has some competition in the market for three-mana, Escape-able Titans. Phlage is a centerpiece in Jeskai Control, and arguably the most efficient way for the deck to close out the game. A 6/6 that sticks around if it Escapes, and has a built-in Lightning Helix when it enters the battlefield. Overall, a potent and powerful creature that synergizes incredibly well with a Jeskai shell, and does what control builds often struggle to do: close out the game. 

Right now the market price for Phlage is around $40, and honestly, I expect it to continue to climb up. Phlage is very powerful, and has utility outside of Jeskai Control as well. It’s easy to slot into a shell that has red or white in it, and has an immediate and repeatable impact on the game in addition to threatening large amounts of damage. 

What’s the long-run for Phlage? In the short-term, I can see Phlage crawling closer to the $50 mark. In the long-run, Phlage is in a bit of an interesting position: on the one hand, it’s widely played in the Modern meta in Jeskai Control and some Ruby Storm lists. The issue with Phlage is that outside of the current Modern meta, it doesn’t really see widespread play in any other format…yet. The adoption rate of Phlage in other formats, especially Pioneer, will dictate its long-run price more than anything. 

As we’ve seen with MH2, LTR, and MH3, the Modern meta is quasi-rotating and can change quickly. With Phlage being so meta-dependent, so too will its long-run price be. That’s the big financial risk with this not-so-gentle giant for the time being. If you want to play Jeskai Control, then Phlage is probably worth picking up sooner than later, but as a long-run spec, I don’t see Phlage being particularly worthwhile. 

Phlage, Titan of Fire's Fury
Phlage, Titan of Fire's Fury (Borderless)

Wish

I’m a sucker for cards that interact with sideboards, or cards that are “outside the game,” more broadly speaking. Obviously, for competitive formats, outside the game translates to “sideboard,” strictly speaking. At the kitchen table on the other hand, well, anything goes! All the same, Wish from Adventures in the Forgotten Realms was once pennies on the dollar. However, with the rise of Ruby Storm, Wish has seen an extreme uptick in demand with its price skyrocketing to around $10.

In Ruby Storm, you’re more often than not only paying two mana for Wish given the cost reductions from Ruby Medallion or Ral, Monsoon Mage. Beyond this, by the time you cast Wish, you’ve already played multiple copies of Manamorphose, Desperate Ritual, or Pyretic Ritual, or a combination of all three, meaning you’ll have plenty of mana to spare for casting whatever you want to with Wish. More often than not, Wish will grab you a Grapeshot and snag you a win consistently on turn three, and a non-trivial amount of times on turn two. 

Wish also has some interesting post-sideboard interactions as well, as you can sideboard cards from your main deck into your sideboard for a higher density of post-board interaction, while enabling you to “Wish Back” whatever you sided out should you need to get access to it at a later point in the game.

So is Wish as a $10 card here to stay? Possibly. I think Ruby Storm is better on paper than Bant Nadu, despite Bant Nadu being the most popular deck by day one statistics. I would expect, short of a ban, that Ruby Storm will be here to stay. Of course the meta will adjust, as evidenced by Trinisphere’s recent spike in price, but I think Wish will continue to see an uptick in demand as more players pick up Ruby Storm as their choice for taking on Modern tables at their LGS or other competitive venues. However, I don’t see Wish going much higher than $20 given its niche use, but I think the current market price is not representative of the peak for this card’s financial potential. 

Wish
Wish (Extended Art)

Kozilek's Command

Just when I thought we’d seen the last Command cycle of cards in The Brothers' War, MH3 gives us the missing colorless Command in the form Kozilek’s Command.

Built into this Command is: card draw, ramp, removal, and graveyard interaction. Quite simply, Kozilek’s Command does it all. Outside of Prison-Style Tron decks, Kozilek’s Command is also seeing play in Legacy and Commander. There’s not much more to say. Pure colorless interaction for Eldrazi Tron has been limited to mainly just Warping Wail in 60-card formats, so Kozilek’s Command is a powerful and versatile upgrade. 

Right now the market price is around $12, and looks to be trending downward. My guess is that this piece bottoms out at around $8 (give or take a dollar). At that point in time, it would be a more than worthwhile spec. The play inside and outside of Modern makes this card valuable beyond just the short-run. At the very least, it’s worth picking up a copy for your Eldrazi Commander decks!

Kozilek's Command

Sink into Stupor & Other MDFCs

The MDFC uncommon cards from MH3 are debatably the best collection of cards from the set. Among these beautiful uncommons, one stands out far above the rest: Sink into Stupor. Sitting at around $4 and leveling off, Sink represents the first time in quite a while that an uncommon has commanded more than a few bucks. In a set like MH3, Sink as an uncommon commanding its current price tag underscores its power and potential.

Seeing play in Modern, Vintage, Legacy, Modern, and cEDH, Sink is becoming a commonplace utility-interaction piece across the entire game. The ability to bounce a troublesome stax permanent or interact with uncounterable spells on the stack is insanely valuable in and of itself. The ability to also act as a blue mana source if needed early in the game is huge. The versatility of Sink into Stupor and many of the MDFC cards in MH3 makes their potential in the long-run quite large. 

Honestly, one cheap pickup speculation I would highly advise is grabbing playsets of the MDFC cards from MH3. They are just that good. Bridgeworks Battle, Waterlogged Teachings, Disciple of Freyalise, Revitalizing Repast, and Pinnacle Monk among others all see play across multiple formats and afford a level of versatility that isn’t accessible outside of these specific cards.

Sink into Stupor
Revitalizing Repast
Bridgeworks Battle
Disciple of Freyalise
Waterlogged Teachings
Pinnacle Monk

The Future

While it is nice to see a fresh meta where Leyline of the Guildpact isn't nearly as ubiquitous, Modern seems to be “rotating” into its new form–for better or worse. The new meta as of Pro Tour MH3 is one that has Nadu at the forefront with Ruby Storm right behind it. Some fans of the format are calling this meta “Nadu Summer,'' in reference to one of the most egregious metas in Modern’s history, “Hogaak Summer,” which was a meta dominated by Hogaak, Arisen Necropolis. Is the current meta shaping up to be on-par with Hogaak Summer? Well, looking at some historical data, during Mythic Championship IV Hogaak occupied a little over 20% of the meta on day one with a roughly 70% conversion rate for day two. In the case of Pro Tour MH3, the percentage of the field on Nadu seems to be roughly equivalent to Hogaak at around 20%. 

What’s more interesting are the cards not seeing play from MH3 at the Pro Tour. Kappa Cannoneer, Flare of Duplication, Buried Alive, and Meltdown are seeing significantly less play than I originally envisioned. Other Pro Tour musings to keep a watchful eye on include Merfolk’s performance and conversion rates from day one to day two. Being the main deck running both Harbinger of the Seas and Flare of Denial, a lot of the financial value of Harbinger in particular hinges on Merfolk’s ability to compete consistently against Bant Nadu and Ruby Storm. The long-run financial value of Flare of Denial thankfully isn’t attached solely to Merfolk, but the highest density of play it will see is likely in Modern Merfolk, so deviations from its current price point will more than likely be tied to Merfolk’s presence in the format. 

Well, that’s all for today folks! Keep a watchful eye on the MH3 Modern meta, which seems to be here to stay. And speculate safely!

Further Reading:

Spicy Cards for Your Colorless Commander Decks

Corey Williams
Corey Williams

Corey Williams is an Assistant Professor of Economics at Shippensburg University in Shippensburg, Pennsylvania. He considers himself a macroeconometrician with his research body reflecting work in applied macroeconomics and econometrics. Corey is an L1 Judge who started playing Magic around Eighth Edition. He enjoys Modern, Commander, cEDH, and cube drafting. Outside of Magic, he loves running, teaching, and the occasional cult movie.


More from Corey Williams:

Expensive Singles from Foundations Jumpstart

A few of the singles from Foundations Jumpstart are commanding extremely high prices. Are they worth it? Will those prices hold? Let's discuss.

Power Creep and The One Ring

Will The One Ring get banned in Modern? Why should it? Let's discuss.

Will Any Reprints from Foundations Affect Modern?

Let's look at some important reprints in the upcoming Magic Foundations set, and see if there's any potential for them to affect Modern.

How is the Modern Meta Shaping Up Post-Nadu?

Did Modern diversify after Nadu got banned, or did a new archetype rise up to take its place? Let's look at the numbers.

Does Mystery Booster 2 Have Any Reprints for Modern?

With 1,800 cards in the set, will Mystery Booster 2 have any reprints for Modern? Find out here.

Will Duskmourn Affect Modern?

Wondering which cards from Duskmourn may have an impact on Modern? This article's got you covered.

Cards Rising in the Post-Nadu Modern

Nadu has finally bit the dust. So let's take a look at the cards rising in the new Modern meta.

Cards to Buy or Sell NOW for Modern

While the world holds its breath for a Nadu ban, other cards in Modern are rising and falling. Should you buy or sell?

Cards to Pick Up While We Wait for a Nadu Ban

While Modern waits for Nadu Summer to end, it's a good time to look at cards that might shine after the ban.

Will Assassin's Creed Affect Modern?

As Modern trudges through Nadu Summer, will any cards from Assassin's Creed sneak into the format?