Weekly Winners Special: 2018 top 100 winners

28 Dec
by Arjen

The end of the year is near! Hope that you all had an amazing Christmas with your loved ones and you're now slowly starting to consider to take it easy for the next few weeks to shake off that little extra bit of weight you put on from the amazing meals. Last week Peter already shared with you a list of the top 100 losers of 2018. As is tradition, I will show you another list. Today, I will present you with the list of top 100 winners.

Calculation method

The most important task in calculating these kinds of lists is the method you use to select, filter, include and exclude cards. Maybe you are missing some cards, or maybe you're surprised about the results. To avoid any confusion I will explain how we have calculated this list. We did it the same as last week, but to recap we will go over this again.

First of all, we excluded all the oldest sets with big prices and little trade. Alpha, Beta, Unlimited, the Dark were excluded from our list. The second important thing to note is that we used the prices of all cards in 2018 on the day of the release of the set. Prerelease prices are known to be inaccurate and some were even listed as $99.99 (or some other ridiculous) price at first. When we take the actual release date prices tend to be more accurate but still a tad high most of the time.

Also note that our 'jan 1st' column is either the price of the card on 01-01-2018, or the price of the card on the day of the release of the set, if that was a date later than 01-01-2018.

Response from last week

Last week when we posted the article on Reddit, and we got some feedback about how the list of losers felt somewhat cluttered to some people. This is due to many cards being in there, for example, that lost a lot of value because they rotated out of Standard. I also read people were interested in a list based on dollar value rather than percentage.

Since the year technically isn't over yet, I've decided to open up a poll where you can vote on which lists you would also like to see. I will take the 2 or 3 top winners and show both winners and losers. I have not done test runs on the poll options, so I may have to make adjustments as I go along. I will write the article on December 31st, so you have until I start writing to vote!

The poll can be found at https://www.strawpoll.me/17124278.

2018: Top 100 winners

Without further ado, here is the complete list. Enjoy!

NameSetNowJan 1st%
Teleport Legends$16.82$2.14+686.0%
Phantasmal Image Modern Masters 2017$18.63$2.54+633.5%
Flying Carpet Arabian Nights$25.84$3.99+547.6%
Phantasmal Image Magic 2012 (M12)$17.96$2.82+536.9%
Gauntlets of Chaos Legends$15.82$2.51+530.3%
Mortify Magic Player Rewards$15.99$2.97+438.4%
Mishra's Factory (Fall) Antiquities$136.50$25.49+435.5%
Absorb Invasion$15.24$2.85+434.7%
Thing in the Ice Shadows over Innistrad$16.50$3.14+425.5%
Psionic Entity Legends$12.02$2.29+424.9%
Clockwork Avian Antiquities$14.99$2.93+411.6%
Ebony Horse Arabian Nights$18.09$3.54+411.0%
Mishra's Factory (Summer) Antiquities$139.99$27.50+409.1%
Strip Mine (Uneven Horizon) Antiquities$94.99$19.10+397.3%
Yawgmoth Demon Antiquities$14.02$2.87+388.5%
Rukh Egg Arabian Nights$11.67$2.43+380.2%
Cosmic Horror Legends$16.45$3.49+371.3%
Divine Transformation Legends$22.89$4.99+358.7%
Strip Mine (Even Horizon) Antiquities$96.10$21.00+357.6%
Land's Edge Legends$78.24$17.13+356.7%
Enchanted Evening Shadowmoor$21.84$5.05+332.5%
Horn of Deafening Legends$20.94$4.86+330.9%
Ball Lightning The Dark$23.99$5.63+326.1%
Angelic Voices Legends$19.20$4.51+325.7%
Carrion Ants Legends$19.14$4.50+325.3%
Elder Land Wurm Legends$17.99$4.24+324.3%
Akron Legionnaire Legends$10.43$2.46+324.0%
Oasis Arabian Nights$11.99$2.91+312.0%
Strip Mine (No Horizon) Antiquities$61.74$15.07+309.7%
Ayesha Tanaka Legends$13.49$3.30+308.8%
Mijae Djinn Arabian Nights$44.95$11.03+307.5%
Strip Mine (Tower) Antiquities$90.24$22.16+307.2%
Urza's Avenger Antiquities$12.28$3.03+305.3%
Jandor's Saddlebags Arabian Nights$33.49$8.28+304.5%
Saproling Symbiosis Invasion$11.39$2.85+299.6%
Jeweled Bird Arabian Nights$11.35$2.85+298.2%
Sakashima's Student Planechase Anthology$25.14$6.38+294.0%
Sentinel Legends$13.11$3.37+289.0%
Squandered Resources Visions$19.34$5.03+284.5%
Petra Sphinx Legends$14.95$4.05+269.1%
Arclight Phoenix Guilds of Ravnica$27.58$7.48+268.7%
Axelrod Gunnarson Legends$12.96$3.56+264.0%
Abu Ja'far Arabian Nights$15.74$4.33+263.5%
Worldspine Wurm Return to Ravnica$17.96$4.95+262.8%
Grim Lavamancer Archenemy: Nicol Bolas$11.49$3.20+259.1%
Ivory Tower Antiquities$19.74$5.53+257.0%
Meekstone Fourth Edition$7.86$2.21+255.7%
Jihad Arabian Nights$274.99$77.47+255.0%
Voodoo Doll Legends$10.19$2.88+253.8%
Rukh Egg [Version 2] Arabian Nights$14.10$4.00+252.5%
Sakashima's Student Planechase 2012$25.00$7.11+251.6%
The Chain Veil Magic 2015 (M15)$15.47$4.40+251.6%
Insidious Dreams Torment$10.00$2.88+247.2%
Temporal Aperture Urza's Saga$7.97$2.30+246.5%
Aladdin Arabian Nights$42.14$12.25+244.0%
Fallen Angel Legends$7.74$2.26+242.5%
Disrupt Decorum Commander 2017$8.39$2.45+242.4%
Karmic Justice Commander 2015$8.06$2.37+240.1%
Recall Legends$97.32$28.70+239.1%
River Kelpie Shadowmoor$7.00$2.07+238.2%
Aladdin's Ring Arabian Nights$29.97$8.93+235.6%
Thrumming Stone Coldsnap$24.99$7.59+229.2%
Pathbreaker Ibex Commander 2015$9.39$2.87+227.2%
Rekindling Phoenix Rivals of Ixalan$25.86$7.94+225.7%
Ezuri, Claw of Progress Commander 2015$12.21$3.75+225.6%
Rohgahh of Kher Keep Legends$39.95$12.27+225.6%
Serpent Generator Legends$14.36$4.49+219.8%
Ob Nixilis, the Fallen Iconic Masters$6.99$2.19+219.2%
Titania, Protector of Argoth Commander 2014$16.37$5.16+217.2%
Jandor's Ring Arabian Nights$23.82$7.56+215.1%
Treasure Map Ixalan$9.41$2.99+214.7%
Elven Riders Legends$15.75$5.01+214.4%
Magnetic Mountain Arabian Nights$9.36$2.98+214.1%
Hammerheim Legends$8.50$2.71+213.7%
Underworld Dreams Legends$88.94$28.49+212.2%
Reconnaissance Exodus$9.00$2.90+210.3%
Kindred Dominance Commander 2017$7.49$2.42+209.5%
Meekstone Classic Sixth Edition$8.65$2.80+208.9%
Expropriate Conspiracy: Take the Crown$34.99$11.39+207.2%
Meekstone Revised Edition$8.12$2.67+204.1%
Meekstone Fifth Edition$7.60$2.50+204.0%
Army of Allah [Version 2] Arabian Nights$11.90$3.93+202.8%
Sylvan Safekeeper Commander Anthology$7.19$2.39+200.8%
Treasure Map Buy-A-Box Promos$17.99$5.99+200.3%
Eye for an Eye Arabian Nights$11.95$3.99+199.5%
Femeref Enchantress Visions$10.00$3.34+199.4%
Varchild's War-Riders Alliances$7.09$2.37+199.2%
Opalescence Urza's Destiny$18.48$6.26+195.2%
Winter Blast Legends$14.00$4.75+194.7%
Junรบn Efreet Arabian Nights$49.95$16.95+194.7%
The Wretched Legends$21.62$7.34+194.6%
Hellkite Tyrant Commander 2016$6.89$2.34+194.4%
Manamorphose Shadowmoor$20.25$6.90+193.5%
Kobold Overlord Legends$69.99$23.90+192.8%
Nature's Will Champions of Kamigawa$16.50$5.67+191.0%
Phyrexian Dreadnought Mirage$42.04$14.54+189.1%
Aura Thief Urza's Destiny$8.95$3.12+186.9%
Manamorphose Modern Masters$20.00$6.99+186.1%
Dakkon Blackblade Legends$45.00$15.74+185.9%
Command Beacon Commander 2015$23.74$8.35+184.3%

 

Top 3 winners

#1 Teleport; +686.0%
Teleport

 

To be fair, Teleport unfortunately isn't that interesting. It's a card from Legends, is not on the reserved list and is also reprinted in Chronicles where the card is less than $0.50. However, it being from Legends easily adds a lot of value to a card because it's rare. I do really like the flavor of this card, I can imagine that when this was printed, the effect felt really good and fun.

 

#2 Phantasmal Image; +633.5%
Phantasmal Image

 

Not only the #2 position, but also the #4. Phantasmal Image already saw play in both Legacy and Modern Merfolk decks, but popularity really took off when Modern started playing it in Spirits and Humans. Since it also only has two prints, the supply is rather limited.

 

#3 Flying Carpet; +547.6%
Flying Carpet

 

Just like the #1, this card doesn't really need a lot of explanation. Printed in Arabian Nights and thus rare. Perhaps it sees play in 93/94 decks? The card has a lot of reprints which are all below $0.50 and except for collector's value, I don't see any other reason for it to have this price tag.

 

Arjen

Arjen

Arjen has been playing Magic since the Ice Age set released. He primarily plays Legacy format and founded MTGStocks over a decade ago when he and his friends wanted to track card prices to purchase singles at optimal times.


More from Arjen:

Weekly Winners 2025 - 51

Dec 19, 2025

As the themes of Lorwyn Eclipsed seem to become more clear, cards are moving up. But Avatar is also still moving prices.

Arjen

Weekly Winners 2025 - 50

Dec 12, 2025

We're talking a lot of Standard today. And while cards from the Izzet Lesson decks are still moving up, we found some different cards to talk about!

Arjen

Weekly Winners 2025 - 49

Dec 5, 2025

Another week full of Avatar and Fire Lords. But mainly because I can, we'll discuss Magic's biggest coward as well.

Arjen

Weekly Winners 2025 - 48

Nov 28, 2025

This week's price winners have achieved perfect balance: They're ALL from the Avatar set. Looks like these cards have mastered the art of wallet-bending!

Arjen

Weekly Winners 2025 - 47

Nov 21, 2025

Another week where Playstation cards are making prices move and Fire Lord Azula remains a popular commander.

Arjen

Weekly Winners 2025 - 46

Nov 14, 2025

Playstation cards and Jaws are responsible for two of our winners this week. The last one is because of a rediscovered combo.

Arjen

Weekly Winners 2025 - 45

Nov 7, 2025

The PlayStation Secret Lair drop is responsible for two of our winners, and the other winner seems to have fallen victim to speculation.

Arjen

Weekly Winners 2025 - 44

Oct 31, 2025

People are still looking for their Rhystic Study replacements. But this week is mostly about cards from Universes Beyond: Warhammer, Avatar, and Spider-Man.

Arjen

Weekly Winners 2025 - 43

Oct 24, 2025

While the market is cooling down a bit, anticipating the release of the next set, the upcoming PlayStation Secret Lair drop is stirring prices a bit.

Arjen

Weekly Winners 2025 - 42

Oct 17, 2025

Spider-Man is making some impact, and the Ninja Turtles are claiming their first spike. But our number one winner is because of Legacy!

Arjen